Published November 15, 2026 in Market Update

Puyallup has more homes for sale, but prices are split

By Thomas Earnest
Real estate, Pierce Co Buy Box

Realtor.com says mortgage rates averaged 7.33% in October 2026 nationally. Even so, Puyallup has more homes for sale right now.

That matters because more listings usually means more room to negotiate. But in Puyallup, the price story is not the same everywhere.

Two ZIP codes, two different stories

The Real Estate Data Aggregator counted a median sale price of $582,000 in ZIP 98373 for the three months ending August 31, 2026. That is up 9.8% from the same months of 2025.

Meanwhile the Real Estate Data Aggregator put the median sale price in ZIP 98374 at $595,508 for the same period. That is down 8% from a year earlier.

So a seller in one part of Puyallup may be seeing gains. A seller nearby may be seeing the opposite.

Puyallup ZIP codes compared
9837398374
Median sale price$582,000$595,508
Change from last yearup 9.8%down 8%
Homes for sale107196
Change in homes for saleup 30.5%up 5.4%
Median days on market28 days22 days
The Real Estate Data Aggregator, the three months ending August 31, 2026.

Both ZIP codes have more homes for sale than a year ago. The Real Estate Data Aggregator shows homes for sale up 30.5% in 98373. In 98374, it shows homes for sale up 5.4%.

More homes for sale gives buyers more choices. It also means sellers have more company on the market.

What is pulling buyers along

Realtor.com reported mortgage rates averaged 7.33% in October 2026, the highest rates of 2026 at the time.

Higher rates raise the monthly cost of buying. That can slow down how fast buyers move, even when more homes are listed.

The Real Estate Data Aggregator shows new listings up 25.7% in 98373 and up 15.2% in 98374, both for the three months ending August 31, 2026.

More new listings mean more fresh choices each month. That can help buyers feel less rushed.

Puyallup at a glance
98373 homes sold
up 26% from a year earlier
98374 homes sold
up 11.7% from a year earlier
98373 months of supply
up 0.1 months from a year earlier
98374 months of supply
down 0.1 months from a year earlier
Source: Real Estate Data Aggregator, the three months ending August 31, 2026

The Real Estate Data Aggregator shows homes sold rose in both ZIP codes. That tells us buyers are still closing deals despite the rate picture.

In short
  1. More homes for sale in both parts of Puyallup, but prices moved opposite ways.
  2. 98373 gained 9.8%.
  3. 98374 dropped 8%.

One street can look nothing like its whole ZIP code. A single sale on your block does not set the trend for the area.

Your next step

(360) 535-4743

Text me your address and I will send back how your Puyallup home compares with the 98373 and 98374 numbers above. Takes a day, costs nothing.

Text me
Where these numbers came from
Thomas Earnest
John L. Scott - South Kitsap & Gig Harbor Regional Office · (360) 535-4743
Privacy policyTerms of useDo not sell or share my informationAccessibility statementFair housing notice
Thomas Earnest is a licensed real estate agent with John L. Scott - South Kitsap & Gig Harbor Regional Office. Market numbers come from MLS records and are believed accurate but not guaranteed. Nothing on this site is an appraisal or a promise of value. If your home is already listed with another broker, this is not a solicitation.
© 2026 Thomas Earnest · John L. Scott - South Kitsap & Gig Harbor Regional OfficeEQUAL HOUSING OPPORTUNITY